Tutorials Home / Tutorial 5

Up

Exercise 5.1 Model Answer
 
Task

Consider this argument, we we have encountered previously.

Now consider this rebuttal:

 

  1. Decide whether the rejoinder is a premise objection or an inference objection.
  2. If it is an inference objection, produce an argument map showing the inference objection as an objection to a co-premise.
 
Model Answer

The rejoinder is a premise objection

 
Discussion

The rejoinder provides evidence that the stated premise, i.e.,

The astronauts seem well-lit at times when they should be in shadow.

is false.  Specifically, it objects to the "at times when they should be in shadow" part of it.  The astronauts should not be in shadow, because they would be lit up by reflected light from the lunar surface.

An argument map would look like this:

 Glossary | Contents

Up

Copyright Austhink 2003-2006

 Last updated 27-Mar-2007