Home / Tutorial 4

Up

Exercise 4.4 Model Answer
 
Task

Now we combine the two passages, and produce an argument map of the whole chain of reasoning:

Hoax believers object to the claim that the Apollo astronauts landed on the Moon, on the grounds that the tyres of the Lunar Roving Vehicle would be likely to explode in the vacuum of space. However the tyres were not of the traditional inflated rubber variety. The purpose-built LRV tyres were actually made from a mesh of zinc-coated piano wire, to which titanium treads were riveted in a chevron pattern. [Based on 8.5]

Note that for this exercise you need not diagram hidden premises.

 
Model Answer

 
Discussion

This 3-layer chain of reasoning is the result of combining two smaller argument maps from the previous exercises:

 

Notice how the primary objection in the left hand argument is seen to be a rebuttal in the right hand argument.

 Glossary | Contents

Up

Copyright Austhink 2003-2006

 Last updated 15-Mar-2007